Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 4 Review: A return to form, but room for improvement

There is something about the Modern Warfare series that has always made it stand out from the rest of the Call of Duty franchise. With Modern Warfare 4, it feels like we’re finally getting a campaign that brings some of that familiar identity back, while also trying a few new things along the way.

This time around, the story takes a slightly different direction, introducing a darker tone built around the idea of justice at any cost. Captain Price is no longer simply following orders. Instead, he is willing to operate outside the rules, working alongside outlaws and making some questionable decisions to achieve his ultimate goal.

It’s a different side of a familiar character, and one that makes for an interesting campaign.

Campaign

One of the biggest positives for me was the way the campaign was structured. Rather than following one storyline from beginning to end, the game gives us three different perspectives.

We have the familiar Ghost team, characters we’ve followed through the previous Modern Warfare games, Price operating independently while working towards his own objectives, and a North Korean perspective that gives us some additional context leading into the conflict.

I genuinely enjoyed this approach. It adds more depth to the overall story and allows you to understand the events from different sides rather than simply following the usual good-versus-bad formula.

The campaign also introduces dialogue and action choices, which initially made me think that our decisions would have a much bigger impact on how the story unfolded. Unfortunately, after completing the campaign, I found that most of these choices were largely cosmetic. It’s still a nice feature to have, but I would have liked to see those decisions carry more weight.

Where the campaign really shines is towards the end, when the different storylines begin coming together. The South Korean forces and US Marines complete their mission against Ri Ju-Young, while Ko remains behind with the hope of helping North Korea move towards a better future.

Meanwhile, the story involving Ghost and Price takes a much more personal turn. The revelation surrounding Archer and Makarov’s family connection adds another layer to the story, while Price’s eventual death gives the relationship between him and Ghost a genuinely emotional conclusion.

Ghost eventually understands why Price made the decisions he did, and the reminder to keep the line is a fitting way to close that chapter.

Even the post-credit scene leaves you with something to think about, as a handler welcomes a new individual into the team before deleting the records of Price, Ghost and Gaz.

Overall, I thought the campaign was very well put together. The mission variety is excellent, the gunplay feels very good, and there are moments where the game really reminds you why the Modern Warfare series became so popular in the first place.

For me, the best moments are when you’re back in the trenches, fighting enemy forces and trying to accomplish something bigger than yourself. Those are the moments where this genuinely feels like a proper Modern Warfare experience again.

Graphics and Technical Performance

Visually, there is a lot to appreciate here. The new graphics engine does a phenomenal job in certain sequences, and when everything comes together, the game can look absolutely fantastic.

However, I did notice some inconsistency throughout the campaign. Some environments and sequences look incredibly polished, while others don’t quite reach that same standard. It isn’t something that ruins the experience, but it does make you wonder why the quality isn’t more consistent.

Performance was generally good, although I did encounter occasional frame-rate drops and a few minor glitches. There were also one or two moments where my character became stuck in the environment. Thankfully, none of these issues were particularly serious or game-breaking.

One area where I would have liked to see more improvement is environmental destruction. Having played games like Battlefield, I would love to see more dynamic destruction in Modern Warfare. Being able to hit buildings with RPGs and eventually bring parts of them down would add another level of immersion to the experience.

Considering the quality of the visuals in other areas, this feels like a missed opportunity.

It also makes you wonder whether giving a Call of Duty release a little more time for refinement could help iron out some of these inconsistencies. I don’t know the actual development timeline, but there is certainly room for improvement.

Multiplayer & DMZ

The traditional multiplayer experience is exactly what you would expect from Call of Duty. It’s familiar, enjoyable and doesn’t necessarily reinvent the wheel.

One thing I particularly appreciate is the movement system. The updated Modern Warfare movement feels much better to me than some of the more recent Black Ops movement mechanics. It’s a welcome change and makes the multiplayer experience more enjoyable.

However, the real surprise for me has been DMZ.

This is probably one of my favourite additions to the game, and honestly, I find myself enjoying it more than standard multiplayer and ranked modes.

DMZ offers a three-player experience where you can jump in with two friends, or simply take another mate along for the ride. The extraction-based gameplay gives each session a little more meaning because there is always something at stake.

You’re collecting additional operators, completing missions and working towards your own objectives. But if you don’t make it to an extraction point or get merked, you risk losing the operator you’ve been using along with their built-up skill tree.

That risk-and-reward element makes things genuinely entertaining, especially when you’re playing with friends. It almost feels like a mini-career of its own, with missions and progression giving you something to work towards beyond simply winning matches. It’s a great little addition, and one I would love to see developed further.

Soundtrack and Audio

The soundtrack deserves a mention because I thought it was really, really good.

I particularly enjoyed the gangster rap tracks used at the beginning and end of the game. They help establish the atmosphere and give the campaign a memorable sense of identity, especially when you reach the conclusion.

It’s one of those smaller details that adds more to the overall experience than you might initially expect.

In typical FPS game style depending on the mode your playing the soundtrack varies, in the campaign for example the score ramps us during intense scenes helping you to identify the “severity” of the scenes and adding that slight bit of additional meat on the bones.

Final Verdict and closing thoughts

Modern Warfare 4 is a strong entry that brings back much of what I enjoy about the Modern Warfare and Call Of Duty series.

The campaign offers an interesting story told through multiple perspectives, excellent mission variety and a conclusion that does justice to the relationship between Price and Ghost. The gunplay is very good, the soundtrack is memorable, and DMZ has turned out to be one of my favourite parts of the entire package.

That doesn’t mean everything is perfect. The dialogue choices could have had more meaningful consequences, the graphics aren’t always consistent, and the technical experience could benefit from a little more polish. I would also love to see more environmental destruction in future releases.

For anyone who hasn’t played the earlier Modern Warfare games, I would genuinely recommend going back and experiencing them first. The remastered versions are worth considering, particularly if you want to appreciate the characters and understand where this story has come from.

At the end of the day, Modern Warfare 4 feels like a return to form. It isn’t without its shortcomings, but there is plenty here to enjoy, and I came away feeling positive about the experience.

Latest Reviews

Latest News

Latest Articles

Good

  • Best Campaign in years
  • Movement mechanics feel genuine

Bad

  • Minor technical glitches impact gameplay
  • COD multiplayer sweats making online multiplayer less fun for the casual gamer

Details

Links

Score

8
Story
Audio
Graphics
Gameplay
Replayability